What should Fund VI pay for a Tokyo building? (EN)

5:39 · English · Acquisitions

Watch this video

Enter your details to access the library. We'll email you a code to verify your address.

See how we use your data in our Privacy Policy.

About this video

A broker's brochure prices a Tokyo retail building at ¥13.5bn. Ellie reads the Japanese data room behind it and works out what Fund VI should really pay.

Full description

Carradale Asia Partners' Fund VI is screening Project Heliotrope, the Jingumae 4-21 Building in Tokyo, offered at ¥13.5bn. Ellie reads the broker's data room, most of it in Japanese, against the fund's own mandate and business plan. The memorandum leads with ¥444.5m of NOI anchored by a flagship tenant, but the flagship has already served notice, and the property manager's schedule shows no replacement. Drawing the lender's capex facility takes borrowings above the LPA's 65% limit in 2028, which the business plan never tested. The lease audit finds break rights the schedules leave out and signage income no licence supports; the technical review prices repairs the plan omits and finds no earthquake cover; the debt review shows the lender sized the loan without reviewing the rent roll. Ellie recommends no more than ¥12.75bn with less debt, and drafts the cited IC memo on the house template.

Key points

  • Reads a Japanese data room against an English memorandum and the fund's mandate
  • Finds the flagship tenant's notice the memorandum leaves out
  • Tests leverage quarter by quarter against the LPA, not just at completion
  • Lease, technical and debt reviews each checked against the documents
  • A cited IC memo on the house template, with a recommended price
Transcript

One manager, Carradale Asia Partners, runs four funds with buildings in Singapore, Tokyo, Sydney, and Dubai. A broker has sent a Tokyo retail building at 13.5 billion yen. Should Fund 6 bid and at what price? This is the deal workspace. The broker's data room holds 80 documents in nine folders, most of them in Japanese. The sale process with the memorandum and the seller's answers. Then every lease in Japanese, the engineering, seismic, and asbestos reports, the lender's term sheet, and our own LPA and business plan.

Ellie files her work in the output folder. The IC memo, the workbooks, the reports, and the slides. Four threads did that work. The IC memo, the lease audit, the technical due diligence, and the debt terms against our LPA. One instruction to Ellie. Run our acquisition screen and IC memo skill. Screen the deal against the fund 6 mandate. Underwrite it from the data room and draft the memo for the 14th of October committee. The memorandum leads with NOI of 444.5 million yen, a 3.29% yield anchored by a flagship tenant.

But the flagship Kobaneya Apparel has served notice. Its own letter in Japanese ends the lease on the 28th of February, 2027. The memorandum does not mention it. The property manager's tenancy schedule says there is no replacement tenant. Income in place falls to 245.4 million yen, 1.82% on the guide price. The second finding is one our own business plan missed. It tests leverage only at completion 58%. Our LPA caps borrowings at 65% of asset value tested every quarter with development values excluded. draw the lender's capex facility through the works and borrowings reach 66 and a half% in June 2028 about 203 million yen over the limit.

The screening brief puts it on one page, the income bridge, the mandate scorecard, and the leverage path quarter by quarter. Ellie's structure stays under the line, peaking at 63 and a half%. Her recommendation, no more than 12.75 billion yen with less debt, 15.7% and 1.97 times above the hurdle. And the memo itself on our house template, the income bridge, the quarterly leverage table, and the mandate compliance table, clause by clause, every figure traced to its page.

Then the leases. Ellie read all 16 documents in the leases folder, most of them in Japanese, and checked them against the property manager schedules. What the schedules leave out matters more. All seven ordinary leases let the tenant leave on 6 months notice, and no schedule shows it. And the rent roll carries 800,000 yen a month of signage. The only license in the room is for 200,000. Income at risk by quarter, a seller query list, and a brief for the acquisitions team.

The building next. Ellie read the engineering, seismic, and asbestos reports and the statutory inspections, most of them in Japanese. The engineering report prices 12 years of repairs at 486 million yen. Our business plan has not added them. So 147.4 million comes on top. All of it equity. And the insurance schedule in Japanese, no earthquake cover. In the severe quake, the report models about 294 million yen would be uninsured. A technical findings memo, questions for the seller, and a brief for the deal team.

Then the debt. Ellie tested the lender's term sheet against our LPA and the lender's own covenants quarter by quarter on the income the leases actually support. The lender sized the loan on the memorandum's income and its own term sheet says it has not reviewed the rent roll. Without the flagship's rent interest cover falls to 1.82 times under the lender's two times minimum. So, she marked up the term sheet and wrote the covering note and the questions for the lender.

The markup removes the equity cure. From a broker's memorandum to a cited IC memo with the leases, the building, and the debt, each checked against the documents before the committee meets.

Fifth Dimension for deal teams

From data room to cited IC memo

Video details
Roles
Portfolio Manager, Investor / LP, Lender
Processes
Acquisitions, Due Diligence, Valuation
Geographies
APAC
Markets
Japan
Tags
apac-pe, acquisition screen, IC memo, Japan, carradale