About this video
Block C is empty, a draft committee paper says fix it up, and a buyer has offered S$16m. Ellie values all four options on the real lease.
Full description
An asset team must decide what to do with Block C, a vacant 1996 warehouse on land that ends in 2041. Ellie follows every receipt behind the approved S$2m (S$2.48m all in, including S$480k of unbudgeted fire works), values hold, enhance, redevelop and sell at the 8% policy rate with a finite terminal, traces every enhancement input to its page and cell, and opens the head lease to show why the value ends in 2041. Selling leads at about S$15.6m against S$15.0m to fix it; nothing is approved. Fictional data.
Key points
- The approved S$2m is really S$2.48m once receipts and fire works are counted
- The draft paper valued the land as if it never ends; the head lease ends 30 September 2041
- Sell S$15.6m vs fix S$15.0m vs rebuild S$14.1m vs hold S$12.5m at 8%
- The buyer's offer is non-binding and open until 31 October 2026
Transcript
One logistics trust, eight parks and 61 leases across Singapore, Japan, and China. Three decisions sit at the bottom of this tree. This one is block C at Tuas South. Built in 1996, empty since 2025 on land that ends in 2041. Fix it or sell it. the asset management team's workspace for block C 46 documents, the funding approval, the tenders, the orders and invoices, the fire notice, the valuation, and the draft paper that is about to go to the investment committee.
The committee approved $2 million. Ellie reconciles every instrument and counts each commitment once. 100,000 already paid and sunk. 300,000 committed on the enabling order. 1.6 million still uncommitted on the revised tender. Open the enabling order. 400,000 of which 100,000 is already paid. And 484,000 of fire safety works that the notice makes compulsory with no budget behind them at all. 2.48 million at completion, 24% over the approval. So it goes back to the committee.
One date matters, the 31st of October. Cancel on the fixed terms by then and it costs 60,000. After that, not less than 130. Now the four options at the 8% policy rate over 5 years with a terminal value that stops when the land lease ends in 2041. Sell 15.62 million. Enhance for strand 15.04 redevelop 14.1 hold 12.45. The annuity factor comes from the valuation note, open it, finite tenure, no perpetuity. The draft paper used a 22 million terminal from a superseded park yield valuation.
That alone invents 4.5 million of value. Here is the line in the draft. Which input moves the enhancement case? Rent by a wide margin. 2.8% more rent and enhancement leads. So refining the capex will not change the decision. Rent evidence will. And the offer on the table is not binding and lapses on the 31st. Before anything goes to committee, Ellie traces every enhancement input to its page and its cell and confirms the terminal value is finite.
Open the head lease. It expires on the 30th of September 2041 with no option to renew. So the value ends there and none of the options has its approvals yet. The committee pre-read opens with the evidence map, then the commitments, the four values, the break evens, the precedent, and the approval gaps. Every figure traced. A value ranking is not an investment approval. Negotiate the sale before the offer lapses. Do not sign it.
Asset performance, always current
Video details
- Roles
- Asset Manager, Investor / LP
- Processes
- Asset Management, Valuation
- Geographies
- APAC
- Markets
- Singapore
- Tags
- author-demo, logistics, capex, Singapore