Still copying last year's questionnaire answers? (EN)

3:42 · English · Risk & Compliance

Watch this video

Enter your details to access the library. We'll email you a code to verify your address.

See how we use your data in our Privacy Policy.

About this video

Ellie checks an investor ESG questionnaire, drafted from last year's answers, against this year's evidence.

Full description

Norbeck's Fund II ESG questionnaire is due on 9 October, drafted by rolling last year forward. Ellie checks the answers against this year's certificates and reports: Marisbrook's Green Mark expired on 31 May 2026 and its recertification is not yet awarded, so the green-certified share (Q14) falls from 100% to 38.6% (S$180.0m of S$466.0m). The Kyoto flood assessment and electricity emissions answers change too. v2: title card shortened to three lines.

Key points

  • Last year's answers checked against this year's certificates
  • An expired Green Mark cuts the certified share from 100% to 38.6%
  • Every changed answer cited to its source
Transcript

Linthurst Norbeck's investor has sent its environmental, social, and governance questionnaire due on the 9th of October and the draft carries every answer forward unchanged. Ellie finds three that changed. First, certified coverage at the reporting date. By value, counting only certificates in force, it is 38.6%. The data room holds last year's response and this year's evidence, green building certificates, operator energy reports, a Japanese engineering report, and the fund's latest valuation.

The portfolio manager asks Ellie to answer from the evidence, not from last year. Starting with portfolio and certification, the live issue is Singapore 61.4% of portfolio value and its certificate has lapsed. Ellie works through the evidence turn by turn. Three hotels in Kyoto, Singapore and Perth. Each certificate is checked against a second source. All three cross checks pass. So Kyoto and Perth hold. Last year's coverage answer was 100% and right when it was given.

Singapore's certificate expired on the 31st of May. Click the date and the Green Mark certificate opens. It lapsed a month before the reporting date and recertification is pending, not awarded. Under Linthurst's own rule, pending does not count. Last year's answer also said, "No hotel sits in a flood zone." Click Kyoto's depth and the Japanese engineering report opens. Ellie translates the key line. The hotel sits in the city's flood hazard area, half a meter to 3 m deep.

The third change is carbon. Last year's response applied Singapore's grid factor to every hotel. Kyoto's operator report states its own factor 0.438. The evidence lands in a data book, each certificate with its expiry and value. Energy and carbon per occupied room on each hotel's own factor and every changed answer last year's against this year's. then Norbeck's response itself. All 62 answers in Linthurst's order. Each is traced to its document and page and the changes are flagged for sign off.

For investor relations, the brief sets out the three changes and every cell is a citation. Click the coverage figure and the investor report opens beside it on the valuation table. This is what a general model is likely to miss. An expiry date, a share of the valuation, a Japanese flood map, and a rule in the fund's own policy site in four different documents. Only read together do they overturn last year's answers. 62 answers from evidence and three wrong ones caught before the investor reads them.

The Fifth Dimension platform

AI for commercial real estate underwriting and lease abstraction, connecting your firm's documents, data, systems and expertise in one platform.

Video details
Roles
Compliance / Risk, Investor / LP
Processes
Risk & Compliance
Geographies
APAC
Markets
Japan, Singapore
Tags
author-demo-2, ESG, DDQ, GRESB