About this video
An off-plan developer sells 288 units on a 50/50 payment plan. The launch tranche falls due on 50% of the Construction Works, every later unit on 50% of the Structural Works, and sales operations invoices the whole book on one date off one certificate.
Full description
Carrowmere Tower, 288 units in Business Bay, 212 sold, AED 1.06bn contracted on a 50/50 plan with no post-handover tail. Two near-identical sale-contract templates differ in one defined term, and the building contract certifies the two packages separately. Ellie rebuilds every unit's Instalment 2 trigger from its own contract, shows 152 units demanded 84 days late (AED 76m, carry AED 1.4m) and the escrow account bridged with AED 52.5m of corporate cash the board report called a timing item, finds seven termination notices computed on amounts paid where Dubai law has said unit value since 2009 (AED 5.85m of lawful retention forgone), clicks every figure through to its page, and returns the corrected demand schedule and the redrafted notices. Closes on the monthly schedule form.
Key points
- Two templates, one word different, two certificates: the whole book was invoiced off the wrong one
- 152 units called 84 days late; AED 52.5m of corporate cash bridged the escrow account while the board read collections as on plan
- Seven termination notices followed a 2019 crib sheet still on the original 2008 wording, a decade after the law moved to unit value: AED 5.85m of lawful retention left on the table
- Every figure clicks through to the certificate, statement or procedure page it came from
- Deliverables, not a diagnosis: the corrected demand schedule and the redrafted notices, then a monthly schedule
Transcript
An off plan developer sells a building that does not exist yet. So the only thing connecting the cash to the concrete is a definition written into a contract. This is Carrowmere Tower. 288 units in Business Bay, 212 of them sold, just over a billion dirhams contracted on a 50/50 payment plan with no post handover tail. And this is the August board report. Collections on plan 100% of installment two demanded on schedule. Green. Every word of that is true on its own desk.
Here is what none of the desks could see. One question put to the whole data room at once for every sold unit. What does its own contract say triggers installment two? And when did that trigger actually fire? Not the register's date, not the board's date, the contracts date. Ellie reads both sale agreement templates, the building contract, every certificate, the demand run, and the escrow statement, and rebuilds the trigger unit by unit. Two templates, and they are near identical.
The launch tranche, 60 units, falls due on completion of 50% of the construction works. Every later unit, 152 of them, on 50% of the structural works. Same clause number, same page, one word different. and the building contract defines those as two separate packages with two separate certificates. The structural milestone certified on the 14th of May. The surveyor certified 50% of the whole building on the 30th of July. Sales operations raised installment 2 across all 212 units on the 6th of August in one run off the surveyor's valuation because that is the document that reaches the collections desk every month.
Here is the tie out red. The proof is one sentence and Ellie found it on the certificate itself. This certificate relates to the structural works package only. It does not certify and must not be read as certifying the completion percentage of the construction works as a whole. 14th of May, 76 million dirhams collectible from that day. Nobody asked for it until August and the sentence the board actually received 100% of installment two demanded on schedule.
Both documents are in the same room. Nobody had read them together. The late cash had a bill. IPC 18 94 million dirhams to the contractor fell due on the 20th of August. The escrow accounts held 41 1/2. The company put in 52.5 million of its own money the day before and the board report called it a working capital timing item. demanded on time. The rev B receipts would have cleared in early June and that check would never have been written. Then the seven units in arrears draft termination notices ready to serve each retaining 25% of the amounts paid.
Dubai law says 25% of the unit value and has since 2009. The notices follow an internal procedure from 2019 whose crib sheet still says in every case a percentage of amounts paid. the wording of the original 2008 law, which the government portal still publishes unamended, 10 years out of date, and nobody noticed. 5.85 million dirhams the company was entitled to keep and did not ask for. And because every purchaser has paid 30% against a 25% cap, the money is already in hand.
No court application. Ellie checked that, too. Total hard money, 7.3 million dirhams against 106 million of mistimed cash. None of it visible in a report that said everything was on plan. And she does not stop at the diagnosis, the corrected demand schedule, all 212 units, the date each should have been called, the seven notices redrafted on the correct base, a covering note to government relations, and an instruction that the 2019 procedure is withdrawn.
Her exact words do not serve those notices as drafted. This runs on the first of every month against whatever certificates have landed before the board pack is written rather than after. two towers, two regulators, one small team. The definitions will keep drifting. The point is that someone reads all three documents together every month and says so.
AI for commercial real estate underwriting and lease abstraction, connecting your firm's documents, data, systems and expertise in one platform.
Video details
- Roles
- Owner
- Processes
- Risk & Compliance
- Geographies
- APAC
- Markets
- United Arab Emirates
- Tags
- offplan-milestone-gap, off-plan, collections, gulf