Paying full price for service your contractor never delivered? (EN)

3:23 · English · Asset Management

Watch this video

Enter your details to access the library. We'll email you a code to verify your address.

See how we use your data in our Privacy Policy.

About this video

Ellie tests every breakdown call-out against the maintenance contract and finds the service credits a building is owed.

Full description

A Singapore office tower's chiller contract renews itself next week, and every monthly report says each service level was met on a 1.4-hour average. Ellie tests each of the 28 critical faults against the contract's 2-hour target: 8 were late, S$37,440 of service credits were never deducted, and there is a right to terminate. Notice must go by Friday 2 October.

Key points

  • Averages hide the late call-outs; the work order log shows them
  • Uncollected service credits quantified
  • Renewal notice deadline surfaced in time
Transcript

Treverton Shenton is a Singapore office tower with three engineering contracts, chiller, electrical, and building management. It is review season and the Chiller contract renews itself for two more years unless written notice goes out by the 2nd of October, one week from today. The managing agents scorecard rates all three contractors green and recommends letting the chiller contract renew. The data room holds the three contracts, the contractor's monthly reports, the managing agents work order log, and the invoices.

Asset management asked Ellie to test every contractor against its own contract, starting with the words that decide the answer. The chiller contract measures response for each critical fault, not as a monthly average. The target is 2 hours and the managing agents work order record governs, not the contractor's report. That matters because the agent scorecard takes the same view, rates all three green, and concludes that no service credits were assessed.

Its figures come from the contractor's own monthly reports which only ever quote the average 1.4 hours across the year and every line marked green. Ellie goes fault by fault through the work order log instead counting the misses and the credits they earn. 28 critical chiller faults and eight were attended after more than 2 hours. Each one earns the building 10% of that month's feedback capped at 30% in any one month. The review lands as a workbook with live formulas.

The contract register, every term taken from the contract. The critical fault register, each fault tested on its own. The service credits month by month tied back to the invoices and a check sheet where every total ties to zero. The same review becomes a dashboard. The three contracts with their notice dates. The eight late callouts picked out of all 46 critical faults and the credits owed month by month and the brief for the head of asset management opens on the finding.

Click any figure and its source opens beside it. That is $37,440 in credits. None of it ever deducted. This is the kind of finding a general model tends to miss. The reports are accurate and the average is inside the target. But the contract tests each fault on its own and the answer lives in a work order log nobody summarized. Ellie read the contract first, tested all three contractors, and found the one that fails one week before it renews for two more years.

Fifth Dimension for asset managers

Asset performance, always current

Video details
Roles
Asset Manager, Owner
Processes
Asset Management
Geographies
APAC
Markets
Singapore
Tags
author-demo-2, vendor management, service levels, Singapore