Is your hotel valuation using last year's trading? (EN)

3:29 · English · Valuation

Watch this video

Enter your details to access the library. We'll email you a code to verify your address.

See how we use your data in our Privacy Policy.

About this video

Ellie checks a Hokkaido hotel valuation's trading assumptions against the operator's latest reports.

Full description

Three draft valuations for Norbeck's Hokkaido hotels assume 74% occupancy from a single unattributed survey. The operator's latest twelve months show 61.8%, and the comparables sit at 63.1% and 58.9%. On achieved trading, the Niseko hotel's value falls from ¥10,900m to ¥8,925m (−18.1%) before the 7 October committee.

Key points

  • Valuer's occupancy traced to its source
  • Operator trading data read against the draft
  • Value impact quantified before the committee
Transcript

Norbeck is a hotel valuation demo. Three Hokkaido hotels in its hotel fund have draft valuations for the 30th of September and the valuation committee signs off on the 7th of October. The data room holds the three draft valuation reports, the monthly operator packs, the management agreements, two listed hotel trusts latest disclosures, and the funds valuation policy. The question asks Ellie to walk through all three drafts, every key assumption, its page, and the evidence the valuer cites for occupancy.

At Sapporo, the valuer adopts 82% occupancy supported by the hotel's own trading and by comparable evidence. Then Niseko against the policy's 10% trigger. The valuer assumes 74% occupancy. The hotel's own year achieved 61.8. The only support the valuer cites is one resort survey with no publisher period or basis. The listed comparables ran at 63.1 and 58.9. Then Ellie reruns the valuer's own method on achieved trading. Niseko's value falls 18.1%.

Value per key is the second breach, 36.6% above the comparables mean. The workbook benchmarks every key assumption against achieved and comparable evidence. Achieved trading links to the monthly operator packs across the full 12 months. Comparable evidence gives each trust's period and basis. Value it achieved reruns his capitalization holding his other assumptions constant. The dashboard sets every key assumption against the evidence across the portfolio.

Value is 10.6% below the drafts. Niseko trades a 4-month winter season and loses money in six months of the year. His own method, rebuilt, matches his income to within 30,000 yen. The letter to the valuer is drafted on Norbeck's letterhead as a written challenge under the policy. It asks for his evidence rather than proposing a value. First, the evidence behind 74% at Niseko. The brief for the committee gives each assumption its period and basis.

Click a figure and the draft valuation report behind it opens alongside. This is the finding a general model is likely to miss. The draft reads as internally consistent. The problem only shows when its assumptions meet the operator's own packs and the trust's disclosures like this one. Two assumptions breach the trigger both at Niseko. Sapporo and Hakodate hold up and the committee challenges Niseko with the evidence in hand.

Fifth Dimension for asset managers

Asset performance, always current

Video details
Roles
Asset Manager, Owner
Processes
Valuation, Asset Management
Geographies
APAC
Markets
Japan
Tags
author-demo-2, hotel valuation, Japan